Investors Financial Services Corp. (IFIN) declined 13% for the quarter and 33.2% year to date. It is our second worst performing stock for the year. UTSI is the worst. The drop in IFIN stock price resulted from declining earnings growth. We looked at IFIN two months ago. This is a relook.
On July 17, Investors Financial cut its earnings forecast. The company gave 2005 earnings guidance of $2.30 a share, with core earnings flat with the year-ago $2.09. The company said 2006 core earnings would rise 8%-10%. Analysts had forecast earnings of $2.50 a share for 2005 and $2.98 for 2006. See page 2 of the second quarter earnings report for the companies explanation.
The announcement predictably drove the stock price down, although the market had already discounted the decline in earnings growth with the stock price slowly declining since February. See IFIN price chart. The bottom feeders of the securities bar immediately filed multiple class actions alleging that management had misled shareholders with false optimism prior to the reduced earnings guidance. The filing of class actions under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 whenever a company announces bad news has become a cottage industry that ought to be closed. The litigating attorneys frequently settle these class actions for their fees and expenses and some minimal compensation to the shareholders. Most of these class actions are a wasteful drain on an overburdened legal system and on the finances of the targeted companies.
Morningstar rates IFIN with three stars, a narrow moat, and a “D” in stewardship, and concludes that it is fairly valued at $35. (It’s current price is $32.90). Manifest Investing gives IFIN a quality rating of 64 and estimates a PAR as 21.2%. The Investors Advisory service also has IFIN as a buy up to $53.
The company’s core business offers a wide range of administration services to mutual fund complexes, investment advisors, family offices, banks, and insurance companies. That business seems to be solid although it operates in a very competitive environment. The company’s banking services have suffered the same slow down as other banks due to flatter yield curve and narrower investment spreads. The market has probably over reacted to the news in July. Our current stock selection guide shows a projected average return of 19.4%. IFIN is a hold for now. However, we have four financial stocks, CBH, FITB, COF and IFIN. We may want to consider pruning back.